العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Community | Florida

CAIR Florida asks federal judge to block state's domestic terror designation

The Florida chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations asked a federal judge on October 28 to temporarily block the state's domestic terror designation and enforcement of a law its lawyers say prevents the organization from operating, the USA TODAY Network-Florida reported on October 29.

CAIR's attorneys told Chief U.S. District Judge Allen Winsor that an IT provider had stopped working with the group, supporters had stopped donating and a student organization had canceled an invitation because they feared penalties under state law. The group said it could have to close within days without court intervention.

Ashley Gorski, an American Civil Liberties Union attorney representing CAIR and its Florida chapter, called the designation executive suppression of speech without an adequate process. Florida's lawyers argued that the law regulates conduct rather than protected speech and that CAIR should seek relief in state court. State attorney Charles Cooper described CAIR as Hamas' largest charitable front, an allegation presented as Florida's position in the report.

The report did not announce a ruling on the request before Winsor. A separate CAIR lawsuit over an executive order imposing a foreign terror designation is before a federal appeals court, according to the outlet.

In a November 4 update, the USA TODAY Network-Florida reported that CAIR had suspended its operations in the state. A sign at its Temple Terrace office said the suspension was due to what the organization called the state's "baseless and unconstitutional" enforcement of its new domestic-terrorism laws. The report described an indefinite shutdown, rather than the possible closure discussed at the earlier hearing.

The outlet also reported that a November 4 notice on CAIR's website said it was not accepting donations from people living or located in Florida and asked Florida residents not to join its mailing lists or otherwise engage with CAIR or CAIR-Florida at that time. The report said the state's designation was due to take effect November 5; it did not report a new court ruling on the request to block it.

Update, November 5: CAIR and CAIR-Florida will appeal a federal ruling that declined to block Florida's designation of the groups, the American Civil Liberties Union said Thursday. The ACLU said Chief U.S. District Judge Allen Winsor found the plaintiffs unlikely to succeed at this stage on their due-process and First Amendment claims, but granted limited preliminary protection against penalties for providing legal services to the groups.

The ACLU said the ruling did not resolve the lawsuit, address all claims or make factual findings about the state's allegations, which the groups reject. It said legal-defense and compliance activities could continue under the ruling and a separate agreement not to prosecute specified good-faith activities, while the organizations' advocacy and operations in Florida remained suspended.

WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.