العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Analysis | United States

They called him a 'jihadist'. Americans elected him.

In the final month of Michigan's campaign, Abdul El-Sayed fought more than his Republican opponent. He faced the country's highest ranks of power: a president, his vice president, three senators, a cabinet secretary and the Republican Party's two campaign arms. They all reached for the same weapon: his religion. The weapon failed.

At 12:52 a.m. on Election Day, before Michigan's polling places opened, President Donald Trump wrote on Truth Social that Abdul El-Sayed "Hates Jews and Hates Blacks" and "also Hates Whites". "Only fools" would vote for him, Trump said, explicitly urging voters to elect his opponent, Mike Rogers. The post was not an isolated attack. It followed a campaign of attacks on El-Sayed. Media Justice Network's report on money, secrecy and the 2026 midterms documented ads that took his words out of context and others that omitted context about his positions on policing and prisons.

A month of organized fire

The campaign began on October 7, when Trump renamed a Muslim opponent born in Michigan "Mohammed" three times in a single post, describing him as a "radical extremist and terrorist sympathizer". On October 25, at a rally in Port Huron, the president said he was there "to keep a jihadist Muslim Brotherhood member from becoming a United States senator". He added that El-Sayed would have to "go through a metal detector before he's allowed to go into the Senate", comparing stopping him to what the passengers of Flight 93 did on September 11.

It did not stop with the president. Senator Ted Cruz called him a "jihadist leprechaun" on October 28. Senator Bernie Moreno imposed an explicit religious test the same day, saying El-Sayed should "not come anywhere near Washington" because rights, for Moreno, "come from God" and Jesus Christ. That prompted the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) to point out that Article VI of the Constitution prohibits any religious test for public office. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., meanwhile, declared in Grand Rapids that "500 million Arabs don't produce science or win Nobel Prizes". On October 30, he doubled down in a lengthy post on X rather than apologizing.

Between those attacks, a Senate Leadership Fund ad falsely claimed that six "extremist" Muslim organizations had backed El-Sayed with more than a million dollars. These are nonprofits legally barred from supporting candidates in the first place. An October 27 audio discussion on X, meanwhile, carried an explicit call to "kill and capture the leaders of Muslim movements", with a Republican congressman present who did not object.

A third of the rhetoric was about Islam

This was not a journalistic impression but a documented measurement. An analysis published by The Washington Post on August 23 found that nearly a third of American right-wing social media posts about El-Sayed addressed Islam, Muslims or Sharia, rather than his economic program or public health record. When PolitiFact examined the central accusation, that he was a "jihadist" and a member of the Muslim Brotherhood, it gave the claim its lowest truth rating, "Pants on Fire", on October 27. The White House had supplied no evidence, it noted. The claim was "made up out of whole cloth", in historian Juan Cole's words. The headwind was real, not merely rhetorical: a Michigan State University Institute for Public Policy and Social Research poll found that 38% of the state's voters said they were "less likely" to vote for a Muslim candidate. The attacks were reaching an audience open to them, in a state Trump himself won in 2024.

Why did the campaign fail?

This is where the deeper lesson begins. As strategists from both parties explained to the American press, the attacks were designed to break El-Sayed's coalition from within: to draw Jewish and Black voters in metropolitan Detroit who had backed his former Democratic rival Haley Stevens away from him by portraying him as a threat to both communities. The Election Day post spelled out that approach. Yet the coalition held. Even Stevens' own defection two days before the vote and endorsement of Rogers did not save the Republicans. For some supporters, the attacks appeared to become a reason to mobilize rather than retreat. In Dearborn, the largest Arab American city, turnout by 2 p.m. on Election Day exceeded the city's entire turnout in the 2022 midterms. The city recorded its highest-ever day of early voting, while officials expected final turnout to exceed that of the 2024 presidential election, a rare occurrence in a midterm. Some of those who helped deliver the 2024 surprise became public voices of regret. Bishara Bahbah, founder of Arab Americans for Trump, said the Port Huron remarks crossed a "red line" and predicted a "complete reversal" of Michigan support toward the Democrats. The NAACP issued a rare condemnation describing the attacks as "blatant racism".

A declared victory. Official certification is a separate process.

NBC News projected that El-Sayed had won Michigan's Senate seat over Mike Rogers, making him the first Muslim elected to the chamber, in a swing state rather than a safe stronghold. That followed Decision Desk HQ's call for him early Wednesday. A media projection does not constitute official certification of the results. Certification remains a later process, separate from declaring a winner. Only a month earlier, Rutgers University published a study titled "Punished for Participating", documenting how Muslim candidacies in America since 2001 have been met with systematic waves of Islamophobia. Michigan in 2026 does not disprove the study: the wave arrived with all its force. But it shows that this campaign, fierce as it was and peaking on the eve of the vote, did not prevent him from reaching the Senate.


Sources

WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.