العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Opinion

From September 11 to Mamdani: How did American Muslims move from defending their identity to shaping politics?

Twenty-five years ago, having an Arabic name or an identity associated with Islam was enough, in some parts of American society, to leave you facing questions that had not been asked before: Are you really American? Where do your loyalties lie? And can your religion be separated from the security suspicions that followed the September 11 attacks?

At the time, Muslim Americans faced more than a passing wave of fear or misunderstanding. They faced a deep change in their place within the society in which they lived. Suddenly, their religious identity became a subject of public debate. They had to explain themselves and defend their belonging, even as doctors, engineers, teachers, soldiers and citizens who had known no homeland other than the United States.

Today, the picture looks markedly different. A quarter-century after those attacks, American Muslims are no longer concerned only with proving that they are part of America. Some of their children now compete to lead it, contest elections and reach positions where decisions are made. Zohran Mamdani's rise to become mayor of New York embodies this change in one of the world's most prominent and diverse cities.

Between these two scenes lies a political, social and cultural journey worth considering: How did a community whose identity was called into question move from defending itself to competing for power?

September 11: When identity came under scrutiny

The September 11, 2001 attacks were more than a security event that shook the United States. They were a turning point that reshaped the relationship between the state and the Muslim community, and influenced how sections of the American public viewed Muslims and Arabs.

The attacks, carried out by al-Qaeda against the World Trade Center in New York and the U.S. Department of Defense headquarters near Washington, opened the door to an exceptional period of security measures. The Patriot Act was passed, surveillance and investigative powers expanded, mosques and Islamic institutions came under scrutiny, and federal programs subjected thousands of men from predominantly Muslim countries to special registration and monitoring requirements.

But the deeper impact was not confined to laws and procedures. It reached into everyday life: a suspicious look at work, uncomfortable questions at school, anxiety about displaying religious symbols, and fears that involvement in political or social activity might become grounds for suspicion or accusation.

It was no longer simply a matter of what an individual did. Often, it became a matter of what their name, religion or cultural background represented in the public imagination.

Politics was one of the most sensitive arenas. A Muslim candidate entered an election carrying more than a platform and a set of positions. They knew their identity might become the focus of a campaign of suspicion, and that their ties to Muslim community institutions could be used against them, even when those ties had no direct connection to their ideas or policies.

Many therefore preferred to stay away from the political spotlight, or limit themselves to less visible roles. This was not necessarily a withdrawal from public affairs. It was a response to a climate in which the cost of participation seemed high and, at times, unequal.

The gap thus widened between American Muslims' growing social and economic presence and their relatively limited political representation.

From establishing a presence to affirming belonging

History, however, did not stop at that moment of fear. Even as the image of the Muslim American was surrounded by suspicion, society itself continued to change, and new generations made their way through its institutions.

Over the next two decades, Muslims strengthened their presence in medicine, universities, schools, business, the armed forces, sports and the arts. This happened not through major campaigns to defend their identity, but through everyday participation in society and through examples that could not easily be reduced to stereotypes.

There were Muslim doctors in hospitals, teachers in schools, officers and soldiers in the armed forces, and academics, businesspeople, artists and athletes moving into public view.

One telling example was American fencer Ibtihaj Muhammad's participation in the 2016 Rio de Janeiro Olympics. She became the first American athlete to compete at the Olympic Games wearing a hijab, and won a bronze medal with her team.

Such examples may seem far removed from politics, but they contributed to a deeper change: moving the Muslim American from an exceptional figure who required explanation to a citizen present across different areas of life, whose daily experience was not fundamentally different from that of millions of other Americans.

More important still was the rise of a new generation born and raised in the United States. This generation attended its schools, spoke English as its primary language, lived its culture, took part in its debates and knew no other homeland.

For this generation, citizenship was not a favor whose recipients had to prove themselves worthy. Nor was an Islamic identity the opposite of an American identity. In their personal experience, the two forms of belonging overlapped rather than necessarily contradicting each other.

This is where the real political shift began: from a generation that felt it first had to prove its right to exist, to one that sees competing to represent and lead society as its natural right.

Gaza: From a foreign issue to a test of domestic politics

The war on Gaza, in October 2023, opened a new chapter in American Muslims' relationship with politics and placed Middle Eastern issues at the center of a broad domestic debate.

The Palestinian issue was not new to the American Muslim community. But after the war, it acquired a different presence as protests spread through cities and universities, and debate intensified over U.S. policy toward Israel, military aid, Palestinian rights and the limits of free expression in educational institutions.

Notably, this debate was not confined to Muslims or Arabs. Americans from different religious, ethnic and political backgrounds took part, particularly among sections of young people and progressive movements.

For many activists and voters, Palestine was no longer merely a foreign-policy matter. It became connected to domestic questions of human rights, justice, civil liberties, public spending priorities and holding power to account.

This convergence created new opportunities for joint political work between Muslims and other groups of voters. It also exposed real differences within American political parties, and between generations and political currents.

For American Muslims, this period brought a twofold test: How could they maintain a presence in public debate without being reduced to a single issue? And how could they turn positions and protests into institutional representation and an ability to influence policy?

Mamdani: When a Muslim reaches the top of local government

In this context, Zohran Mamdani's rise to the office of New York mayor takes on a meaning that goes beyond his personality and electoral platform.

Reaching the leadership of America's largest city is more than an electoral achievement for a Muslim candidate. It is a striking milestone in the history of Muslim political representation in the United States. It is a scene that would have been difficult to imagine in the years after September 11, when an Islamic identity alone was enough to raise questions about loyalty and belonging.

But Mamdani's importance does not lie solely in his being Muslim. He is a politician from a new generation who presents himself through a clear political and social message, and takes part in public debates about housing, the cost of living, transportation, services and economic justice, alongside his positions on foreign policy and the Palestinian issue.

His experience therefore cannot be read only as a story of religious identity, or reduced to his ethnic and cultural background. It is also a political experience that reflects change within a city of many races and religions, and shows how local issues and electoral coalitions that cross identity lines can reshape the political scene.

In Michigan, physician Abdul El-Sayed offers another example of Muslim politicians' presence in public life, through his career in government and politics and his participation in debates about the future of the Democratic Party and political representation.

These examples do not mean that Muslims have become a single electoral bloc, or that they share a unified position on domestic and foreign issues. The American Muslim community is diverse in its origins, interests and political leanings, as is American society more broadly. What these experiences share, however, is an expanding space for participation, and a retreat from the idea that an Islamic identity is an insurmountable barrier to public office.

Advancement does not mean Islamophobia has ended

Still, it would be a mistake to read this change as the end of the difficulties American Muslims have faced.

Islamophobia has not disappeared, and discrimination against Muslims remains present in parts of society and public life. Debate over Islamic identity is no longer confined to social discussion, but appears clearly in election campaigns and political and media rhetoric.

Reports by rights organizations, including the Council on American-Islamic Relations, continue to record growing numbers of complaints involving discrimination, harassment and attacks against Muslims. The positions of some candidates and public figures also show that religion and cultural background are still sometimes used in political disputes.

Mamdani himself has faced criticism and attacks, some of which focused on his Islamic identity and his positions on Israel and Palestine, in a debate that at times moved beyond policy differences to questions of belonging and identity.

Here lies the paradox of the present moment: Muslim Americans have a greater presence and ability to compete, but they have not entirely escaped the old battles over their right to be an ordinary part of political life.

Indeed, the nature of the battle has changed. The question is no longer always whether a Muslim American belongs to society. Debate now also concerns the policies they defend, the coalitions they build and the vision they want to offer for the country's future.

That is an important shift in itself. Disagreement over a political platform is different from questioning its advocate's right to participate in the first place.

From a seat at the table to a role in decision-making

Over a quarter-century, American Muslims' place in public life has changed. They have moved from a period dominated by security fears and social pressures to one in which their participation in elections, institutions and civic movements is expanding, and some reach leadership positions.

But measuring this change solely by the number of elected officials is not enough. Its deeper importance lies not in having a Muslim mayor or a Muslim member of Congress, but in a Muslim candidate's presence becoming ordinary, and their platform being discussed on the basis of their positions and performance, rather than their religious identity becoming an exceptional issue that precedes everything else.

Nor does the success of this presence depend only on Muslims electing candidates from their own background. It depends on their ability to build broad coalitions, participate in issues that concern society as a whole, and offer ideas that can be debated and contested within the American political system.

Democracy does not grant a group permanent influence simply because its numbers grow. Influence is shaped by organization, participation, coalition-building and the ability to turn demands into policies and institutions.

From this perspective, the story of American Muslims since September 11 is more than a transition from fear to confidence, or from marginalization to representation. It is a story of change in the understanding of citizenship itself: from trying to prove belonging to exercising its rights, and from asking for space in public life to competing to determine its priorities.

A quarter-century ago, the question that haunted many American Muslims was: Are we part of this country?

Today, another question has begun to assert itself: What role can we play in shaping its future?

Between those two questions lies the story of twenty-five years of change. It has not ended the old challenges, but it has changed where those facing them stand on the map of American politics.

The ambition is no longer simply to sit at the table. Some American Muslims have begun to help decide what is put on it, and who makes the decisions about it.

WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.