العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Opinion | Editorial Board

Islamic Centers in the Election Bazaar

On October 21, Marc Roberts, a real estate investor and co-founder of Miami's famous E11even club, sent a mass email, a copy of which reached a reporter, urging recipients to pressure Florida Governor Ron DeSantis and local mayors to stop Islamic center projects in Delray Beach, West Palm Beach, Loxahatchee and Vero Beach. As reported by The Real Deal on October 26 and followed up by the Miami New Times on October 28, Roberts offered no evidence for his accusations against the projects. Instead he offered a single sentence that sums up the scene: the centers would attract people "violently opposed to our biblical worldview," and he asked, "Do we want to end up like Dearborn, Michigan, or other states currently governed by individuals holding this ideology?"

The question was never about a mosque in a Florida suburb. It was, as the documented record of the past two years in the American press shows, a question about an entire community.

A Sequence of Facts

The Delray Beach project itself was approved in 2023 and includes a mosque, a school and a day care, yet its opponents keep packing city commission meetings; an October 3 meeting ended with protesters wearing swastikas shouting antisemitic slurs in the civic center parking lot, according to reports by WPBF cited by the Miami New Times. In response, local interfaith clergy spoke up for the project. Rabbi David Steinhardt, co-president of the Boca Raton Interfaith Clergy Association, told WPTV: "When you don't know people, then you suspect people, and when you're suspicious, you fear people. And so when you fear people, then you don't necessarily act rationally." He reminded viewers that the people behind the project "have been in town for decades. We have worked together at the hospitals, in the courts, in business, in all different arenas of public society."

In Texas, Governor Greg Abbott announced five state investigations within roughly one week in the spring of 2025 into "EPIC City," a project of the East Plano Islamic Center, and ordered construction halted before it had even begun, embracing the "Sharia city" label that developers and civil rights groups disputed, according to public radio station KERA. In June 2025, the U.S. Department of Justice closed its own investigation into the project, according to the Associated Press. In a separate case elsewhere in North Texas, in August 2026, Texas Congressman Keith Self appeared before the McKinney City Council to urge it to reject a permit for a mosque on 5.5 acres, invoking "child marriage" and "honor killings" and citing an unverified figure about Britain's "grooming gangs," as documented by the Dallas Observer, which noted that Self is up for reelection this November. But after hours of tense public comment, the council unanimously approved the zoning request at that same meeting, finding the plan "fully compliant" with city rules; specific building permits will be considered individually.

In Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, the city council voted 4-1 on January 13, 2026 to reject a rezoning request for a mosque and a community center with a food pantry and a medical clinic, after weeks of objections laced with hostility toward Muslims and Islam; Islamic Society and CAIR representatives said churches had obtained approvals for similar applications. Notably, according to a USA Today report on August 3, 2026, the mosque file became campaign fodder between two gubernatorial candidates before it was even decided. It then became a federal lawsuit filed by the Islamic Society of Tulsa and the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) under the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, and the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division opened a review of the city's zoning practices.

In Marlboro, New Jersey, the Marlboro Muslim Center filed a federal suit on September 28, 2026 after the zoning board denied its application to build a mosque on land it owns, capping a five-year permitting process that began with its first application in September 2021. The mayor denies the denial was rooted in Islamophobia, according to nj.com on October 17, 2026.

From Neighbor Dispute to Campaign Wedge

These local files do not stay local. Reuters headlined on September 8, 2026: "Republicans are making Muslims a campaign issue in the 2026 US midterms." It documented Vice President JD Vance calling Abdul El-Sayed, the Democratic Senate nominee in Michigan, "very, very evil"; Senator Tommy Tuberville, running for governor of Alabama, where Muslims make up less than half a percent of the population, warning that "the enemy is inside the gates"; Republican lawmakers founding a "Sharia-Free America Caucus"; and Representative Randy Fine introducing legislation he says will "tackle the rise" of sharia law in the United States.

NPR documented on September 10, citing the nonpartisan Center for the Study of Organized Hate, that 46 elected GOP officials published more than 1,100 posts targeting Muslim Americans with bigotry and conspiracy theories between February 2025 and March 2026. In August, Representative Nancy Mace wrote that "every single Muslim holding public office in America is a trojan horse, and a threat to both national security and our republic." And on October 26, two days before this was written, President Donald Trump, at a Michigan campaign rally, called Abdul El-Sayed a "jihadist," said he "would be the only senator that will have to go through a metal detector before he's allowed to go into the Senate," and repeated an accusation of Muslim Brotherhood ties without evidence, according to Axios, which noted that El-Sayed has repeatedly denied the accusations and no evidence has emerged for them.

Why? A Legitimate Question With Attributed Answers

Why does a mosque permit become rally material? The editorial board cannot claim to know anyone's intentions, but the analysts interviewed by major news organizations offer a converging reading. Aaron Hughes, a University of Rochester professor of religious studies, told Reuters: "If you can wrap yourself in the flag and you can criticize Muslims and Islam that means you don't really have to deal with the issues," calling it "fear-mongering." Maya Berry, executive director of the Arab American Institute, told NPR: "It's something that's being driven and is rooted in a political agenda. It's rooted in a desire for a viral moment online. It's rooted in a desire to fundraise for their campaigns." Republican consultant Dennis Darnoi told Axios the rhetoric could "energize and mobilize" the base in a close race, adding with arithmetical candor: "It's not always about winning, but if you can minimize the size of your loss and then go into more Republican areas and gin up your turnout... then you can win a very close statewide race." For their part, those involved deny religious motive: an Abbott campaign spokesman said the Texas governor's actions concerned "alleged illegal conduct, not religious beliefs"; the White House told Axios the president is "calling out the radical extremists stoking division"; and a Republican strategist told The Hill the attacks are "not anti-Muslim, it's anti-socialist."

The Social Bill

The cost is documented too. The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) counted about 8,683 civil rights complaints reported to it in 2025, in its annual report released March 10, 2026, the highest since it began keeping records in 1996, though just 0.3 percent above the previous year, with Florida, Illinois, Minnesota, Oklahoma and Texas each recording rising complaints for a third straight year. A Michigan State University poll cited by Axios found 38 percent of Michigan likely voters less likely to support a Muslim candidate, though 58 percent said a candidate's faith made no difference. Raqib Naik, executive director of the Center for the Study of Organized Hate, describes the scene to NPR as "an open season on Muslims," warning of its link to the "great replacement" conspiracy theory in whose name deadly attacks were carried out in Buffalo, Pittsburgh and El Paso. These numbers do not, by themselves, prove a direct causal line from any one speech to any one incident; what they document is a widening climate of complaints and fear.

The rupture does not stop at Muslims. In the Delray Beach civic center parking lot, it was swastikas and antisemitic slurs. Two years earlier, Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, were the target of a fabricated rumor amplified by leading candidates, as Reuters recalled. A fire lit for electoral mobilization knows no neighborhood lines. That is where Maya Berry's words return: "You're not thinking about what happens to a young Muslim girl in school or young Muslim boy in college. There's a direct harm to all of this in terms of its impact on people."

A Countercurrent

Yet the picture is not all dark. In South Florida, rabbis and pastors publicly defended their Muslim neighbors in the name of decades of shared life. In Oklahoma and New Jersey, the mosque denials are being tested in federal court, while the Justice Department is reviewing zoning practices in Broken Arrow specifically. In Michigan, a majority said a candidate's faith does not matter to them. And an American president, George W. Bush, once stood at an Islamic center days after the September 11, 2001 attacks to say America does not blame a community for the deeds of individuals, as Berry recalled, adding: contrast that with what you hear today.

The Editorial Board's Word

At Mahjar Post, we report these facts attributed to their sources. We do not claim to know what is in people's hearts, and we do not establish what evidence has not established; the Miami email offered no evidence for the accusations it carried, according to the published reports. But the documented record is enough to say plainly: when building a mosque becomes election material, the first victim is not Muslims alone, but the very idea of equal citizenship. And to the Miami email's question of whether America wants to end up like Dearborn, the answer it deserves is this: Dearborn is an American city, its citizens are Americans, and its mosques are American, just like its churches. America does not "end" when its citizens build their houses of worship; that is where it begins.

WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.