Mahmoud Al-Hamza: Arab science needs stronger institutions, not stereotypes
In a November 2 opinion essay for Al Jazeera, Mahmoud Al-Hamza rejects U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s generalizations about Arab and Muslim contributions to science and literature. Responding to remarks at a campaign rally in Michigan, he argues that differences in knowledge production reflect historical and institutional conditions rather than fixed limits in a people's abilities.
Al-Hamza writes that research funding, university independence, education quality, freedom of inquiry and institutional stability shape scientific output. Wars, displacement, brain drain and weak scientific cooperation can prevent qualified researchers from turning their abilities into sustained work, he argues.
He rejects blaming the challenges facing hundreds of millions of people on a single political group, the Muslim Brotherhood, as Kennedy did. Assessing the influence of any movement on education requires evidence and comparative analysis, he writes.
A meaningful response, in his view, must go beyond recalling past achievements or listing scientists. He calls for independent universities, equipped laboratories, lasting research funding, room for criticism and experimentation, policies that retain talent, and institutions that connect education with the economy and innovation.

