Judge rejects bid to halt operator selection for Mamdani's grocery plan
Mahjar Post - New York
A federal judge on Friday, November 20, denied a request to stop New York City from selecting private operators for Mayor Zohran Mamdani's planned discount grocery stores. The ruling rejects a preliminary injunction, not the entire antitrust lawsuit, and does not mean an operator has been selected or a store has opened.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon ruled that the National Supermarket Association and two grocery businesses had not met the requirements for preliminary relief against the city and the New York City Economic Development Corporation. The plaintiffs argued that taxpayer-supported discounts would threaten private competitors through predatory pricing.
Rochon found that the plaintiffs had not shown a dangerous probability that the program would later recover losses by charging monopoly prices after weakening competition. She cited its continuing discount requirements, ordinary retail pricing for other goods and the city's lack of a profit incentive. She also found that the balance of hardships and the public interest weighed against an injunction, citing food access and affordability.
The plan calls for five publicly funded, privately operated stores, one in each borough. A core basket of groceries would carry an average discount of 30% relative to retail prices; the requirement does not cover every product. The plaintiffs intend to continue the case and review their options, their lawyer Richard Lawson told Courthouse News Service.
Sources: U.S. District Court, SDNY, case 1:26-cv-07729 (JLR), opinion and order, November 20, 2026, copy hosted by Courthouse News Service; Courthouse News Service, Josh Russell, November 20, 2026

