Michigan Supreme Court declines appeal over mail-ballot counting guidance
The Michigan Supreme Court declined on October 29 to hear an appeal challenging Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson's guidance on absentee ballots with missing or mismatched ballot stubs, Michigan Advance reported. The decision leaves in place an appeals-court ruling allowing those ballots to be counted as challenged ballots under the guidance.
The lawsuit was brought by national and state Republican Party organizations and Chesterfield Township Clerk Cindy Berry. The Supreme Court's order said it was not persuaded that the questions presented should be reviewed. The court did not issue a majority opinion explaining the decision.
A Court of Claims judge had ruled in December 2025 that ballots with mismatched numbers could not be counted. The Court of Appeals reversed that ruling in June 2026, saying state law did not prohibit counting absentee ballots with missing or mismatched stubs as challenged ballots. Benson's lawyers had argued that the absence of specific instructions in the law left the decision within her authority.

