العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Analysis | Michigan

How did the Muslim Brotherhood become central to the electoral battle in Michigan?

A few weeks before this article was first published, Republicans' difficulties in Michigan's U.S. Senate election appeared clear. The party's candidate, Mike Rogers, faces Democrat Abdul Mohamed El-Sayed, who is of Egyptian origin, and opinion polls clearly showed the Democratic candidate leading by more than five points. When attempts to frighten voters with his Muslim-identifying name and to label him a "jihadist" failed, Republicans turned to linking him to the Muslim Brotherhood, whose Egyptian branch the United States classifies as a "specially designated global terrorist" organization.

Abdul's platform centers on lowering the cost of living, getting corporate money out of politics, ending military aid to Israel and healthcare for all. Rogers, meanwhile, is preceded by his reputation as someone who voted several times to raise Americans' drug prices during his previous service in the U.S. House of Representatives. He also supported the U.S. war on Iran, which raised fuel and goods prices for voters, despite his recent attempt to call for an end to it.

What is Abdul's mother's relationship with the Muslim Brotherhood?

During the weeks before this article was first published, Republicans found what they were looking for in a deleted 2010 tweet by Abdul's half sister, Eman, to use against him. She indicated that their mother and family had long been connected to the Muslim Brotherhood. On October 12, 2026, the Republican National Committee and Rogers launched an advertising campaign seeking to connect Abdul to the group and Hamas, and the ad tried to associate them with the September 11, 2001 attacks. Rogers circulated the ad and wrote above it on X that, according to Abdul's sister, Abdul had long belonged to the Muslim Brotherhood. He added that Abdul should be honest with Michigan residents about "his and his family's relationship with terrorism."

Right- and left-wing media published details of the ad. Interviewers focused on questioning Abdul about membership in the Muslim Brotherhood during interviews and events. He declined to answer several times, stressing that he was being asked because of his religious affiliation rather than his identity, and said what mattered was his policies, what he said and his commitment to the U.S. Constitution.

Trump had targeted Abdul since he won the Democratic primary nomination. On Truth Social, Trump posted two pictures: one of himself and his wife, labeled Donald Trump, and the other of Abdul and his wife wearing a hijab, labeled Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed. Above them he wrote: "Two very different Americas." In comments on the post, Trump supporters called for stopping the spread of Islam in the United States, barring Muslims from office and expelling them from the country.

Trump also posted an AI-generated image with the word "Jihadists" in red, featuring a map of Michigan and Minnesota alongside Abdul El-Sayed's name and picture and a picture of Representative Rashida Tlaib wearing a hijab, although she does not wear one. A red arrow connected each of them to an image representing a mosque. Trump used the same approach with Representative Ilhan Omar in Minnesota. This was the first time a U.S. president had used a description branding members of the U.S. House of Representatives as "jihadists."

On October 8, 2026, Trump attacked Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed, targeting his name and Arab and Muslim identity. In a Truth Social post, Trump focused on the name "Mohamed," after focusing in earlier attacks on "Abdulrahman." He wrote that "Mohamed's values do not suit the people of Michigan and do not align with the values of the great United States ... Mohamed El-Sayed is a very bad candidate for the Democrats, while his opponent Mike Rogers (Republican) is excellent. Mohamed takes us back to the days of jihad. He is a radical extremist and terrorist sympathizer, no different from his closest friend Hasan Piker, who hates America."

The escalation following the campaign to link him to the Brotherhood then came from Trump himself. Asked by journalists on Wednesday, October 14, 2026, about the Democratic candidate's membership in the Muslim Brotherhood, Trump claimed that Abdul had announced his membership years earlier and had been "proud to belong to it." He said Abdul "cannot be a member of the Muslim Brotherhood inside Congress and hold a position on one of our security committees." Republicans have placed the seat at the heart of their electoral battle, seeking to prevent the first Muslim from reaching the U.S. Senate.

Trump continued using the strategy he has mastered throughout his career to attack opponents, repeating the claim as fact. In a White House speech on Thursday, October 15, 2026, he said: "His name is Abdul. But I call him Mohamed Abdul El-Sayed. He definitely belongs to the Muslim Brotherhood, 100%." He then mocked the possibility of Abdul sitting on the Senate Intelligence Committee, urging supporters to work to prevent his victory in the November 2026 midterm elections.

In an NBC interview, presenter Tom Llamas asked Abdul about old tweets by his half sister, including one saying that their mother was active in the Muslim Brotherhood in the early 1970s, when she was a university student. Abdul's Egyptian immigrant parents separated when he was three. His mother, Faten Elkomy, left Michigan, and his stepmother, Jacqueline Johnson, raised him. Abdul objected to the question, saying: "Are you serious? Are you asking me now about what was happening in Egypt in 1970? I was born here in 1984, grew up here in Michigan, went to university and rebuilt the health department in this city."

When Llamas pressed him, Abdul said he had no connection to the Muslim Brotherhood. This was the first time he answered the question that Republicans had fueled over the weeks before this article's first publication. He said: "I have no connection to them. We have no connections." He added that he had not had such conversations with his mother and had not been raised by her, describing "relying on hearsay from a tweet" as "not serious."

Abdul became exasperated with questions about an issue he says he is asked about because of his name, identity and religion. The questions increased and discussions took place both in his presence and in his absence. Each time he was asked, he responded more sharply about why the question was being raised instead of focusing on his electoral program and confronting him with American voters' demands. Everyone ignored that he had already said he had no connection to the Brotherhood. Republicans had closely examined his statements, views and articles after Egypt's January 25 revolution, but had found nothing real linking Abdul to the group. Bridge Michigan had also investigated these claims and concluded in a report during the months before this article's first publication that there was no evidence Abdul had pledged support to the group or had a direct organizational connection to it.

Nevertheless, Republicans bet that connecting him to the Muslim Brotherhood, on the basis of his half sister's post, would be their route to keeping Abdul out of the Senate after previous accusations failed. These included accusations of terrorism, highlighting his name Abdulrahman rather than the name he is known by, Abdul, and Trump's singling him out as Mohamed rather than his name and asserting that he did not fit Michigan's or the United States' values.

The effort to link Abdul to the Brotherhood gives him a gift before the election

Yet these efforts may have given Abdul a special moment about two weeks before the November 2026 election, as The Wall Street Journal described it. At a campaign gathering on Saturday, October 17, 2026, a young man who gave his name as Tommy asked Abdul whether he would disavow the Muslim Brotherhood. The Democratic candidate answered briefly: "Certainly yes, absolutely." He then turned the tables on his Republican opponent and those asking the question, saying such questions promote bigotry against Muslim Americans. He compared what happened to him with what former U.S. presidents John Kennedy and Barack Obama had faced.

Abdul answered the question with a question about why such things were being asked and used it to denounce attacks targeting his Muslim faith. He added that President Kennedy had faced similar accusations of "dual loyalty" because he was Catholic, and Obama because his father happened to be Muslim. He said: "You are asking this question because you implicitly assume that I have dual loyalty, don't you? I am not running to be a Muslim. I am running for the U.S. Senate, and I happen to be Muslim."

It later emerged that the young man was Thomas Teipel, a former Republican candidate for governor of Kansas and former aide to Republican Missouri Senator Josh Hawley. Clips of the exchange spread widely, and Abdul's campaign used the video to promote him. Abdul wrote on X: "This is Tommy. He had a question about my loyalty. Listen to the end to learn about his." The clip continued to circulate widely on social media up to this article's first publication.

First published in Arabic in Al-Araby Al-Jadeed on October 20, 2026. Published in Mahjar Post on October 29, 2026.

Translated from the Arabic article. Temporal references have been clarified; the author’s text and views are retained.

WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.