العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Community | New York

Muslim association sues Islip over zoning ruling that bars students from living at Bay Shore school

The United American Muslim Association, a Long Island Muslim organization, has asked a New York state court to undo an Islip zoning ruling that would keep students from living at an Islamic school it plans to open in Bay Shore, The South Shore Press reported on Oct. 26.

Background, as reported by the paper: the association filed an Article 78 petition in Suffolk County's state Supreme Court against Islip's Zoning Board of Appeals. It asks a judge to throw out the board's September decision and restore the town's earlier finding that boarding was allowed on the property. The association plans to run Bay Shore Academy there, a parochial school that pairs regular classes with Islamic study and worship, with about 120 boys enrolled and living on campus and roughly 20 faculty and staff also living there. The campus at 26 South Saxon Avenue, in a Residence AAA zone, was a seminary and boarding school run by the Montfort Missionaries from 1926 until 1972, according to the paper.

The dispute turns on whether housing students counts as an accessory use under the zoning code. According to the petition, a town plans examiner told the association in writing, before it bought the land, that a parochial school was allowed in the district and that students could board there. The association says it relied on that answer when it closed on the purchase in June. Two residents appealed the examiner's ruling in May, and the zoning board heard the appeal on July 21. The paper said opponents pointed to the academy's website and promotional materials, which they said described a day care and outside events. A lawyer for the association told the board those activities were not part of the proposal and disavowed an earlier promotional video. In September the board sided with the residents on boarding: it agreed an Islamic school was a permitted use but concluded the dormitory plan fell short of what the code requires of an accessory use.

In the court filing, the association's attorneys argue that the board ignored decades of boarding at the same address, misread the zoning code and relied on speculation about activities the group had left out of its application. They also say opponents made anti-Muslim remarks during the board's public hearing.

The association is represented without charge by the law firm Linklaters. Partner Muhammad Faridi said in a statement: "The faith of the students may change; the law's protection must remain constant. The anti-Muslim sentiment expressed at the hearing has no place in zoning matters." Mahmut Salihoglu, who heads the association's Dix Hills branch, said the group chose the campus "because of its long history of religious boarding education" and went ahead "in reliance on the Town's written approval." He said: "We remain committed to opening the school and creating that opportunity for our students and families, in harmony with the broader Bay Shore community."

Source: The South Shore Press (Oct 26, 2026)
WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.