Pinellas meeting hears objections to mosque expansion; woman removed after playing call to prayer
A woman wearing a face veil was escorted out of a Pinellas County commissioners’ meeting after playing a recording of the Islamic call to prayer during public comment, Fox News reported on October 28. The October 27 meeting also heard objections to an approved land-use change for Masjid Al Rahman.
Chairman Dave Eggers told the woman to stop the recording, saying public-comment rules required people to speak rather than play recordings. A sheriff’s deputy escorted her out, and the sheriff’s office said she would not face criminal charges, according to Fox. The report said it was unclear whether the gesture was a protest or a prank.
Fox quoted a speaker opposing the mosque expansion who described Islam as a totalitarian ideology opposed to American values and women’s rights. Another speaker supported the mosque and said its neighbours had had no problems with it for many years.
A county presentation dated October 27 said commissioners had approved the land-use and zoning changes unanimously on June 16, followed by a 4-3 countywide land-use vote on October 13. It said the county attorney’s office found the public notices lawful and identified no legal defects or basis for further proceedings.
The presentation said the county’s term “meeting hall/community assembly facility” includes religious and nonreligious uses under terminology updated in 2019 following guidance on federal religious-land-use law. It said the mosque application and related plans explicitly described a place of worship.
Update, October 29: Neighbor disputes claims of local opposition to mosque rebuild
Marc Washburn, who lives across the street from Masjid Al Rahman in Tarpon Springs, said opposition at the Pinellas County Commission meeting did not reflect the neighbors he knows, WTSP reported on October 29. He described the congregation as quiet, friendly and respectful and said he supported replacing its aging building.
Washburn told the station that much of the opposition came from outside the immediate neighborhood and from people involved through social media. He submitted a handwritten statement supporting the mosque. WTSP reported that no appeal of the rezoning decision had been filed as of its broadcast.
Update, November 1: CAIR condemns disruption as an anti-Muslim hoax
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) condemned what it called an "obvious anti-Muslim hoax" on November 1 after a woman wearing a niqab played a recording of the Islamic call to prayer (adhan) during public comments at the October 27 Pinellas County Commission meeting in Florida. CAIR National Deputy Director Edward Ahmed Mitchell described the incident as an attempt to "weaponize Islamophobia" and urged residents and officials to reject manufactured provocations.
The Tampa Bay Times reported on October 30 that a Sheriff’s Office incident report identified the woman as Kaitlin L. New, also known as Kaitlin Noethen, who had sought to run for the county school board in 2022. She had signed up to speak as Celine Al Jamal. The newspaper said deputies removed her for violating a rule against playing recordings, allowed her to leave, and that she did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Update, November 3: Rodolfo Mienert, 68, was arrested Monday after deputies accused him of posting a Facebook threat against Pinellas County Commissioner Brian Scott over his vote approving the mosque expansion, FOX 13 reported, citing the sheriff's office. Investigators said they traced the account's IP address to Mienert, who confirmed the account belonged to him. Sheriff Bob Gualtieri condemned the threat and said authorities would enforce the law against such threats. The sheriff's office said Mienert was a retired New York City police sergeant.

