Quebec school principals warn against banning pupils’ religious symbols
School principals in Quebec fear that banning pupils from wearing religious symbols could lead some children to leave school, Le Journal de Québec reported on October 28. The Parti Québécois government pledged during the election campaign to prohibit "ostentatious" religious symbols among primary-school pupils.
Kathleen Legault, president of the Montreal association of school principals, said she knew of pupils wearing symbols including hijabs, kippahs, kirpans and turbans, but was not aware of a problem serious enough to justify legislation. She said children have a right to public, free education and warned that some could drop out if forced to remove their religious symbols.
Francis Côté, president of the Quebec federation of school principals, said religious symbols were not currently a problem in schools. He expressed concern that a ban could damage ties with families. Both leaders urged the government to focus instead on urgent needs, including retaining qualified staff and repairing aging school buildings.
Update, October 28
Education Minister Joël Arseneau said on October 28 that the Parti Québécois government would keep its commitment to prohibit ostentatious religious symbols among primary-school pupils, calling it non-negotiable, Le Journal de Québec reported. Speaking on the sidelines of a cabinet meeting, he said the party would fulfill its election promises in education and other sectors despite school principals’ concerns.
Canadian Muslim Forum response
The Canadian Muslim Forum opposed the proposed ban on religious symbols for primary-school pupils in a statement published on October 29 and dated October 28 in Montreal. The group said the proposal raised concerns about children's rights, freedom of conscience and equal access to public education.
The forum urged the Quebec government to reconsider the ban, consult affected communities and focus on staff retention, school infrastructure, violence prevention and student achievement.
Update, October 29: Muslim groups rally against the proposed ban
The National Council for Canadian Muslims gathered with representatives of other religious communities outside Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon’s downtown Montreal office on October 29 to oppose the proposed ban on religious symbols for primary-school pupils, CityNews reported. Stephen Brown, the council’s CEO, spoke at the gathering. The proposal would cover items including hijabs, kippahs, turbans and crosses.
In a statement published on October 29, Québec solidaire’s education and secularism spokesperson Roxane Milot said the party would vote against the proposed ban. She urged the government to focus on staff shortages, school repairs, reducing dropout rates and student achievement.

