Opinion: Schumer once decried GOP silence on Trump's attacks on Omar, and is now the silent one, TPM's Christopher Mathias writes
In a piece published October 26, 2026 by Talking Points Memo, writer Christopher Mathias argues that Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer has been silent on the federal raid on Rep. Ilhan Omar's home, after criticizing Republicans for silence on Trump's attacks on her in 2019. The following summarizes the author's argument and the facts and statements he cites. The framing and judgments are his.
Mathias recalls that on July 18, 2019, Schumer gave a Senate floor speech defending Omar (D-Minn.) after President Trump's rally in Greenville, North Carolina, where the crowd chanted "Send her back!" Schumer called the episode "despicable" and "eerily familiar to what happens in dictatorships," and said of Republicans: "Our Republican friends are silent. History will show this. This is a moment."
Mathias writes that 14 days have passed since agents from Homeland Security Investigations and the Department of Justice raided Omar's Washington home, part of an investigation that, according to the Wall Street Journal, seeks to denaturalize and deport her over allegations of immigration fraud that he calls dubious. He says House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and former President Barack Obama have denounced the raid as politically motivated, while Schumer has issued no statement or interview about it. Mathias writes that Schumer's office did not respond to TPM's repeated requests for comment.
The author says Schumer's silence has led to speculation that Omar's stance on Israel, which she has said is committing genocide in Gaza, may be a factor, and cites Jeet Heer of The Nation as noting that establishment Democrats have often kept their distance from her. He notes that Schumer did condemn the January attack on Omar at a Minnesota event, when a man sprayed her with liquid from a syringe and was later sentenced to 14 months in prison.
Mathias argues the Trump administration's pursuit of Omar is itself arguably political violence. He reports that Omar told MS NOW's Chris Hayes she and her family will move from the raided home because the raid publicized her address and she receives frequent death threats. He adds that Trump has called Omar "garbage" and "scum," and that the Washington Post reported this month that in 2019 the administration had Homeland Security Investigations scrutinize her immigration records but "ultimately determined there was insufficient evidence of wrongdoing."
He writes that Jeffries and Obama placed the raid in the context of the Justice Department being used against Trump's critics, but did not mention the president's attacks on Somali Americans or what he calls his Islamophobia. As examples of anti-Muslim rhetoric, he cites quotes from Republican lawmakers compiled by Mother Jones, including Rep. Andy Ogles ("Muslims don't belong in American society") and Rep. Nancy Mace ("Every single Muslim holding public office in America is a Trojan horse").
Edward Ahmed Mitchell, national deputy director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), told TPM in a statement that he would "certainly urge Senator Schumer to join many of his colleagues in denouncing the Trump administration's partisan and punitive witch hunt into Congresswoman Ilhan Omar," and that "many of his colleagues and many Americans want and expect to hear from him." Minnesota state Sen. Zaynab Mohamed told The Intercept: "If the president can threaten to denaturalize and deport a member of Congress, no one is safe."
Mathias concludes it is "a crucial moment to stand up for Omar" and that those who do not "will be remembered," quoting Schumer's 2019 words: "History will show this. This is a moment."

