Tulsa Islamic Society challenges Broken Arrow immunity claim in mosque lawsuit
Lawyers for the Islamic Society of Tulsa challenged Broken Arrow’s claim of immunity in a federal lawsuit over the city’s denial of rezoning and a permit for a mosque, the Broken Arrow Sentinel reported Oct. 31.
The society’s lawyers responded Friday to the city’s motion to dismiss. They argued that legislative immunity protects council members when they pass laws of general application, not when deciding how a single applicant may use a specific property. They said the zoning and conditional-use decisions were administrative rather than legislative.
The city’s lawyers argued that council members were protected by legislative and quasi-judicial immunity, including for zoning and land-use decisions. Council members named in the lawsuit have said they rejected the applications because of infrastructure concerns, including sewer service, a single entrance and exit, and the two-lane road serving the site.
The lawsuit, filed on the society’s behalf by the Council on American-Islamic Relations, alleges that the denial violated federal religious land-use protections.

