A snowball rolls through Washington: From candidates' revolt against AIPAC money to Trump's announcement of an end to Israel funding
Mahjar Post - New York
President Donald Trump's announcement on election morning that he had agreed with Benjamin Netanyahu to end the roughly $4 billion the United States pays Israel annually by the end of this year was neither an isolated event nor a passing electoral whim. It was the loudest link in a chain that began months earlier, when American candidates, Democrats and Republicans alike, began treating money from the pro-Israel lobby as a burden to disown publicly rather than a prize to flaunt.
In a telephone interview with Fox & Friends on Tuesday morning, November 3, Trump said: "Bibi Netanyahu and I made a deal under which we give Israel $4 billion a year, and we agreed months ago that we're stopping... We already agreed that by the end of this year we won't be paying Israel, but we'll help them if they need it." Asked whether he meant military or cash assistance, he replied: "Define it however you want... Four billion dollars of things and money, and they don't need it." Arms sales, however, will continue without limits: "They can buy whatever they want." He linked the cutoff to the cost and to removing a "bad talking point" from Democrats, himself citing Abdul El-Sayed as an example of the "lunatics" who kept attacking Republicans over the issue.
But the ball did not start with the president's phone call. Throughout the 2026 election cycle, the scenes accumulated: candidates pledging to reject AIPAC money; others returning it after accepting it, with Rep. Pat Ryan returning about a quarter-million dollars linked to the committee; and a senator of Cory Booker's stature announcing he would no longer accept donations from outside groups, including AIPAC. In Michigan, AIPAC's super PAC spent more than $30 million supporting Haley Stevens in the Democratic primary and trying to defeat Abdul El-Sayed. El-Sayed won despite the money, not because of it, and turned the spending against him into a badge of honor in his victory speech. In New Jersey, the committee spent $2.3 million against Tom Malinowski, who lost to the more left-wing Analilia Mejia. Even in the Republican camp, Rep. Thomas Massie, against whom the committee spent $3.6 million to unseat him, joked in his concession speech that he was late because he had been looking for his opponent "in Tel Aviv." In New Jersey, too, the committee saw no "path to victory" in Adam Hamawy's district and did not spend a dollar.
Then came a step almost unimaginable just a few years ago. On October 21, AIPAC itself announced, in a letter signed by its president to members, that it would no longer publicly endorse any candidate, make direct donations through its political action committee or route members' donations to particular campaigns. It was ending its well-known strategy adopted when it first entered direct endorsements and campaign funding. Its United Democracy Project super PAC will, to be sure, continue independent spending, more than $83 million this cycle, and individual members' giving will continue and expand. But the political meaning requires little explanation: a name once considered a kingmaker in Washington now prefers to work without a signature. The committee's leadership warned members: "The challenges we are confronting will continue to grow in the years ahead," an implicit acknowledgment that the environment has changed and the tables have turned.
The revolt extends from the lobby's money to the underlying issue: the idea that American taxpayers fund a wealthy, distant country. This criticism, long whispered on the fringes of the left, is now voiced on campaign stages and recorded in opinion polls. Gallup registered the first lead in its history for sympathy toward Palestinians over Israelis in February, 41 percent against 36 percent. Pew found that 60 percent of Americans view Israel unfavorably, and the Chicago Council on Global Affairs found that 56 percent want aid to Israel reduced or stopped. When a New Jersey candidate says "Healthcare, not bombs" and wins 70 percent of the vote, and a Michigan candidate builds his victory on "the people beat the money," the issue is no longer a position on the Gaza war alone. It concerns an entire American social contract: why is other people's security funded from taxpayers' pockets while Americans' hospitals and schools are left with debt and austerity?
Against this background, Trump's step takes on its proper meaning: a president sensing the direction of the wind before it blows in his face. Yet there is a distance between words and policy that must not be concealed. Netanyahu's office has not yet confirmed his agreement to an end-of-2026 deadline. Israeli officials expressed surprise at its immediacy, and military commentators in Tel Aviv said the date had not been part of discussions or formally agreed. The documented starting point is that Netanyahu himself proposed a gradual reduction over a full decade; Trump accelerated the end alone. Nor can the president cancel congressionally approved appropriations with a stroke of his pen. He can slow deliveries, decline a new memorandum of understanding and propose zero funding in his budget, but an actual cutoff goes through the two chambers that Democrats reclaimed on the night of his announcement. CAIR summed up the critical position precisely: the statement is an "unprecedented admission" that Americans reject funding Israel, but selling weapons instead of giving them away is "just as immoral," and the words cannot be accepted as fact "unless it becomes a reality."
Whatever becomes of the announced deadline, the picture is complete, at least symbolically. The ball began with candidates rejecting and returning the lobby's checks, passed through a lobby that decided to hide its signature from public view, and reached a president announcing, from his campaign phone, the end of funding that had been sacred in American politics just a generation ago. Snow does not melt quickly in Washington, but once it rolls downhill, it does not return to the top.

