العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Opinion | The Rubicon

Opinion: When Muslim identity becomes a test of belonging

In an opinion column for The Rubicon, the student newspaper of St. Paul Academy and Summit School, Yasmin Khan argues that President Trump's attacks on Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed turned his Muslim faith into grounds for suspicion rather than treating him as a political opponent. She points to Trump's description of him as a jihadist and what she describes as a false association with the Muslim Brotherhood. She contrasts this with John McCain's 2008 refusal to question Barack Obama's identity, and argues that the assumption that an Arab or Muslim is foreign to American society and a source of danger remains entrenched. Turning to Minnesota, Khan cites Minnesota Compass's estimate of about 112,000 Somali residents in 2024, and writes that the community is increasingly reduced in national politics to the stereotypes and prejudices pinned on it. She discusses the fraud scheme linked to the nonprofit Feeding Our Future, which exploited federally funded child nutrition programs during the pandemic, noting that the organization's founder and executive director, Aimee Bock, was sentenced to 500 months in prison in May 2026. Khan stresses that those responsible deserve accountability while rejecting holding the community responsible for their crimes, and argues the case has been used to judge an entire community through the crimes of a few of its members, warning that once the distinctions between individuals and communities blur, "identity starts to function as evidence." Khan extends the argument to Representative Ilhan Omar and urges students to verify claims and ask whether criticism targets actions or assigns blame by identity.

Summary of an opinion article by Yasmin Khan, The Rubicon (student newspaper), November 19, 2026. The views expressed are the author's.

WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.