From a flipped legislative seat to university tuition: where representation changes beyond Washington
Preliminary results from Illinois, Michigan and Minnesota show the story is not just the number of faces in Congress. University and school boards make financial and educational decisions, but a national tally of gains requires matching people and offices rather than adding incompatible figures.
Not every advance in Arab and Muslim representation led to Washington. In suburban Illinois, the Associated Press called Nabeela Syed's victory in a Republican-held state Senate seat, according to Shaw Local, as she moved from the House to the Senate. In Michigan, victory reports placed Amir Makled and Shereef Akeel on the boards of two universities with powers over spending, tuition and choosing a president. [15, 17, 18]
An important difference lies between those pictures: taking a seat from another party is not the same as retaining an existing position, and an education seat is not an honorary title. Understanding these elections requires knowing the kind of authority a candidate will exercise, rather than merely counting names.
Mahjar reviewed preliminary results and the powers of the offices in a set of cases from Illinois, Michigan and Minnesota. These are documented cases, not a statistical sample of all elected Muslims or a final census of winners. Counting continues in some races, so we distinguish a lead in results from a media victory call and from a certified result.
A political transition, not merely an additional name
Shaw Local reported that the Associated Press called Syed's victory at 11:15 p.m. Tuesday, November 3, Illinois time. The newspaper's snapshot, published at 12:05 a.m. Wednesday, recorded 48,051 votes for her against Republican Darby Hills' 36,282, with about 95% counted, according to the newspaper. These are the figures in that published snapshot, not a final tally or certified result. [15]
Syed had served in the House since the 2022 election, while Hills was appointed to the Senate seat in 2025. The result therefore combines a sitting lawmaker's move to another chamber with Democrats taking a Republican seat; it does not mean Syed entered the legislature for the first time. This illustrates the change lost when representation is reduced to a count of names. [15]
Education is a place of authority, not an honorary title
In Michigan, WEMU reported on November 4 that Amir Makled and Paul Brown won eight-year seats on the University of Michigan Board of Regents. In the AP totals it cited, Brown placed first with 27.2% and Makled second with 25.5%. At Wayne State University, AP called the victories of Shereef Akeel and Richard Mack, according to MLive; its snapshot recorded 2,209,893 votes for Akeel, or 25.7%, with an estimated 94% counted statewide. These are victory reports, not official certification. The percentages are shares of candidate votes in races allowing more than one selection, not shares of all voters. [17, 18]
The Arab American News described Makled and Akeel as Arab American lawyers in its April coverage of their selection at the Democratic convention. That establishes the context of their candidacies, but it does not turn a convention result into a general-election result or make their voice automatically representative of every Arab or Muslim. [2]
The university explains that Michigan's Board of Regents has eight members elected statewide to staggered eight-year terms, with general supervision and control over the institution's expenditures. At Wayne State, the board's official page lists powers including choosing the university president, spending, setting tuition and other policies. Election to a board therefore provides access to specific institutional authority, not merely symbolic presence. [3, 4]
School is also a place of authority
At the school level, The Michigan Daily reported on November 4 that Rima Mohammad, Becca Hogan, Brandon Smith and Aaron Puno won four-year seats on the Ann Arbor school board. Citing Washtenaw's unofficial results at 3:21 a.m. Michigan time, it reported that all precincts had been counted; Mohammad received 17.58% of candidate votes, second to Hogan. That is not a share of all voters or a turnout percentage, and completed counting does not turn the result into official certification. [19]
The board's official page confirms that Mohammad is a current member whose term ends in 2026. On her campaign website, she identifies herself as the daughter and granddaughter of Palestinian refugees and says she was elected to the board in 2022. Her new term, according to The Michigan Daily's victory report, therefore retains existing representation rather than automatically adding a new Arab seat to the tally. [6, 7, 19]
The school district lists the board's responsibilities: appointing the superintendent, developing policy, approving curriculum and the budget, overseeing facilities and approving collective bargaining agreements. Those details give a local race its direct connection to families' lives. [8]
Remaining in an institution is part of the story
In Minnesota, preliminary official data recorded 29,733 votes for Omar Fateh in Senate District 62, or 97.30%, with 26 of 26 precincts reporting, against 826 write-in votes. In District 63, Zaynab Mohamed received 44,769 votes, or 87.92%, against Diane Napper's 6,023, with 31 of 31 precincts reporting. Complete precinct reporting does not make the figures certified results. [9]
The Senate pages show that Fateh chairs the Higher Education Committee in the 2025-2026 session, while Mohamed is vice chair of the Jobs and Economic Development Committee and has memberships including housing and finance. We do not assume these roles automatically continue into the new session. They show, however, that retaining a seat can preserve experience inside an institution, a different matter from electing a new face for the first time. [10, 11]
Why is there no single honest number yet?
CAIR and CAIR Action announced on August 20 that their directory identified 255 Muslim elected officials, including 98 in local councils and 63 in education. That is 161 out of 255, or 63.1%, in the two categories combined, according to the publisher. It is a pre-election baseline, not the outcome on the evening of November 3. [12]
The organization says its identified total increased after receiving information about officials omitted from the initial count. Its published directory combines a graphic showing 255 with introductory text giving smaller totals. As the coverage expands, a change in the total cannot be treated as net electoral gains without matching the names and coverage. [12, 13]
Likewise, "more than 160 candidates during the cycle" in CAIR's subsequent announcement does not match lists covering a narrower range of candidates. Nor is Arab identity the same as the Muslim faith. We therefore do not divide the winners we documented by one of those figures to manufacture a false national success rate. [14]
The evidence currently supports a story in which not every advance means a new seat and not every victory creates a unified political bloc. Representation acquires meaning from the nature of authority and from new victories, holds and losses considered separately. A clear record of people, offices and results will make this election tally useful, not a celebratory number that gets ahead of the count.
Sources
[1] WDIV, early snapshot of Michigan board races. Evening text replaced its figures with the victory reports in [17, 18].
[2] The Arab American News, context of Makled and Akeel's candidacies, April 24.
[3] University of Michigan, board and powers.
https://regents.umich.edu/regents/
[4] Wayne State, board powers.
[5] Washtenaw County, unofficial results portal. Updated victory report and snapshot in [19].
https://electionresults.ewashtenaw.org/electionreporting/nov2026/index.jsp
[6] Ann Arbor Public Schools, board membership and seats in the 2026 election.
https://www.a2schools.org/board-of-education/board-of-education
[7] Rima Mohammad, self-description and context of her first election.
https://www.rimaforaaps.com/meet-rima
[8] Ann Arbor Public Schools, board responsibilities.
https://www.a2schools.org/board-of-education/boe/board-recognition
[9] Minnesota Secretary of State, preliminary Senate results.
https://electionresultsfiles.sos.mn.gov/20261103/stsenate.txt
[10] Higher Education Committee, 2025-2026 session.
https://www.senate.mn/committees/committee_bio.html?cmte_id=3124&ls=94
[11] Minnesota Senate, Zaynab Mohamed and current committees.
https://www.senate.mn/members/member_bio.html?leg_id=15588
[12] CAIR, announcement of the directory of 255 officials, August 20.
[13] Directory PDF, differences between introductory text and graphic.
[14] CAIR, November 3 announcement of cycle tracking.
[15] Shaw Local, AP call of Syed's victory, call time and seat context, November 4.
[16] NBC Chicago, Illinois Senate District 26 figures and estimated vote percentage.
[17] WEMU, Makled and Brown's University of Michigan board victory, November 4.
[18] MLive, AP call for Akeel and Mack on Wayne State's board, November 4; figures uncertified.
[19] The Michigan Daily, Mohammad, Hogan, Smith and Puno elected to Ann Arbor school board, November 4.

