العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Analysis | United States

Asma Uddin: What Sharia means under US law

In an October 29 article for The Conversation, law professor Asma Uddin explains that Sharia is not a single legal code. For Muslims, she writes, it is a framework for religious and moral life, including prayer, fasting, charity and family matters. Fiqh is the human effort to interpret those principles, and interpretations vary across Islamic traditions.

Uddin distinguishes voluntary religious practice from a government imposing religious rules. Muslims in the United States are subject to the same laws as everyone else, she writes. Religious commitments can guide personal choices, but they have no independent authority to override US law or the Constitution.

American courts may consider religious agreements through ordinary legal rules, Uddin explains. A marriage agreement promising a payment known as mahr can be considered under secular contract standards, without deciding Islamic theology. Voluntary religious arbitration may also be enforceable, as in Jewish or Christian settings, but an award can be set aside for fraud, coercion or exceeding the agreed authority.

Uddin also addresses coercive policies in countries including Iran and Afghanistan and notes debates among Muslim scholars and reformers over equality and freedom of conscience. She argues that those disputes should not be confused with an individual choosing to wear a hijab or observe religious practices in the United States.

Against the background of anti-Sharia political campaigns, Uddin writes that treating ordinary Muslim practices as political threats can undermine religious freedom. Her article distinguishes religious observance within American law from claims that Muslims seek a separate legal system.

Source: explanatory article by Asma Uddin in The Conversation (Oct 29, 2026)
WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.