العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Analysis | Michigan

From 69% for Biden to a Trump victory, then a major return: What do Dearborn's ballots say about Arabs in America?

In six years, Dearborn voted three times in three different political languages: near-total loyalty to the Democrats in 2020, punishment in 2024, and a major return in 2026 unlike the original loyalty. Reading the city's numbers rather than its slogans, as analysis rather than a claim of measurement, suggests that this vote is neither inherited nor bought. Treating Dearborn as an indicative case, not a representative sample of all Arabs in America, it is a vote granted for one election cycle, on conditions.

No American city is a truer mirror of the Arab vote than Dearborn. This is an analytical description, not a measured judgment: its concentration of Arab residents is unmatched, its election record is documented precinct by precinct, and its mood changes quickly enough to reveal what national averages conceal. Comparing 2020, 2024 and 2026 is therefore not an exercise in nostalgia, but an analytical attempt to assess the nature of an entire voting bloc.

2020: Loyalty was the starting point

In the 2020 presidential election, Joe Biden won 68.8% of Dearborn's vote. This was more than an ordinary lead for a Democratic candidate. It expressed a stable relationship between the city and the party: the city voted, the party reaped the result, and the margin required no explanation. Neighboring Hamtramck, with its substantial Muslim and Arab population, was moving in the same direction: Donald Trump received only 13% there in that election. Starting here makes the scale of what happened four years later clear. A collapse can be measured only against the height of its starting point.

2024: The punishment that changed the city

In 2024, the picture reversed completely. Trump won Dearborn with 42.5%, against 36% for Kamala Harris and 18% for Green Party candidate Jill Stein. In Hamtramck, Trump jumped from 13% to 43%. In this analytical reading, the central development was not the city's move to the right, but its withdrawal of trust from those in power during the Gaza war. The distribution of the punishment itself is telling: some votes went to Trump, while another share, no less significant, went to a third party with no path to power. In the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) 2024 exit poll of Michigan Muslims, Stein received 59%, against only 14% for Harris. In this analytical reading, the message was punitive before it was electoral: those managing the war would be held accountable, even if the alternative was a protest vote without power.

Election Dearborn
2020 presidential Biden 68.8%
2024 presidential Trump 42.5%, Harris 36%, Stein 18%
2026 midterms, Michigan U.S. Senate El-Sayed 82.16% (unofficial city summary)

2026: Exceptional turnout before any result

The story of 2026 began with turnout, not the result. By 2 p.m. on Election Day, Dearborn's turnout had exceeded the city's total turnout in the entire 2022 midterm election. The city also recorded its highest-ever day of early voting, with 1,824 early votes cast on Sunday, according to the Detroit Free Press. Ordinary midterm campaigns do not produce participation like this. It reflects mobilization that sees voting as a consequential act, rather than a passing obligation.

Statewide, the Associated Press called the Senate race for Abdul El-Sayed in the early hours of Wednesday, November 4, according to a Jewish News Syndicate (JNS) report that documented the call and attributed it to AP. More than 95% of the expected vote had been counted, and his tally at the time of the call was 2,497,852 votes (52.5%), against 2,162,890 for his opponent Mike Rogers (45.5%). These were the figures at the time of the call, not a final certified result.

In Dearborn itself, the city clerk's office published its complete unofficial results summary, covering 42 of 42 precincts. El-Sayed's lead there became a known figure, not an impression, as the next section shows. The report observes a clear methodological limit here: Wayne County has unofficial precinct-level details, but certified precinct-level statements of votes have not yet been published. This report therefore does not present any 2026 precinct-level figure as certified.

The most precise detail of 2026: A difference in the margin, not the winner

The most striking detail in Dearborn's results remains what initially appeared to be a split between voting methods. The complete figures put it in its proper perspective. According to Dearborn's own complete unofficial summary, covering 42 of 42 precincts and issued by the city clerk's office in the early hours of November 4, El-Sayed won the city with 37,025 votes (82.16%), against 7,593 for Rogers. He won separately under every voting method: early voting, 7,936 to 1,139; Election Day, 21,740 to 4,176; and absentee voting, 7,349 to 2,278.

Jocelyn Benson, the Democratic candidate for Michigan governor, received 32,617 votes (78.78%). Her share among absentee voters was 77.2%, against 75.0% for El-Sayed. The difference between them was therefore not who won among absentee voters, but the margin of victory alone, a difference of about 2.2 percentage points. City turnout was 45,460 voters out of 79,867 registered voters (56.92%). All these figures remain unofficial pending Wayne County certification.

Gaza alone is not enough to explain it: School bonds

It would be a mistake to read all the mobilization of 2026 as an echo of Gaza alone. Voters faced another question on the same ballot that had no connection to foreign affairs: $1.5 billion in school bonds. According to Dearborn Public Schools officials, these were the largest school bonds to date in Michigan's history. They affect every family with a child in a public school and every homeowner in the city. A ballot question like this mobilizes voters whom foreign policy does not motivate in the first place, increasing the overall turnout that benefits the major races at the top of the ballot.

An honest distinction between the two factors is therefore a methodological duty. Gaza and the regional war largely explain, in an analytical reading rather than a measurement of individual voters' motives, the direction of the Arab vote when it turns out. But they do not alone explain the scale of participation. Part of that scale came from a purely local issue involving deteriorating classrooms and schools that need rebuilding. Confusing the scale with the direction was a mistake in many readings of 2024, and it should not be repeated in 2026.

What does Dearborn suggest about America?

Reading Dearborn as an indicative case, rather than a generalization about all Arabs in America, suggests that its Arab voter has become a mature, punitive voter who knows the value of a vote in a swing state. In 2020, that vote went to the Democrats without apparent conditions, and they took it for granted. In 2024, it was withdrawn when voters considered their administration a partner in the war. In 2026, it returned, not to the party as a permanent home, but against a new administration that inherited the war and expanded the rhetoric of targeting.

The return is therefore conditioned by what preceded it: a contract for one election cycle, revocable at the first test. Anyone in Washington who fails to understand this, Democrat or Republican, will rediscover Dearborn in every election cycle, in the same harsh way.

What remains open

Sources

Related analysis

El-Sayed leads Benson in Dearborn: The gap changes among absentee voters

WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.