العربية

Arab & Muslim News in the US and Canada

Analysis | United States

El-Sayed leads Benson in Dearborn, but absentee voters reverse the gap

Mahjar's analysis of complete unofficial results finds 4,408 more votes for El-Sayed than Benson, but differences in counted votes and voting methods rule out reducing the gap to a single partisan shift.

Abdulrahman (Abdul) El-Sayed received 4,408 more votes than Jocelyn Benson in Dearborn, although both ran as Democrats in the November 3 election. That overall advantage conceals an opposite pattern among absentee voters: there, the candidate for governor led the Senate candidate by 75 votes.

The small gap in that group, compared with El-Sayed's larger advantages in early voting and on Election Day, limits any reading of the city as a single electoral bloc. This is what Mahjar's calculations from the complete unofficial results show, not a survey of motives or identity.

These calculations use the City of Dearborn's summary of the November 3, 2026 election. The file covers 42 of 42 precincts and includes early, Election Day and absentee voting. The city describes it as final unofficial, not certified. The file is timestamped 12:42 a.m. Wednesday, November 4, and the city's page places its update at 12:43 a.m. Michigan time. [1, 2]

There were 45,460 ballots cast out of 79,867 registered voters, a turnout of 56.92%, according to the city. El-Sayed received 37,025 votes against Benson's 32,617, a gap of 4,408 in the Senate candidate's favor. That is not a count of voters who switched allegiance, nor does it identify those voters or explain their choices.

The gap is concentrated on Election Day

In early voting, El-Sayed received 7,936 votes to Benson's 6,859, a difference of 1,077. On Election Day, his advantage rose to 3,406 votes: 21,740 against 18,334.

Among absentee voters, however, Benson led by 75 votes, receiving 7,424 against El-Sayed's 7,349. The overall gap is therefore not a uniform pattern across the three voting channels; adding the votes conceals that difference. Adding the gaps, 1,077 plus 3,406 minus 75, produces 4,408.

The comparison does not establish that voting method caused the difference. These groups may differ in composition, and the file provides no data connecting each person's choice with age, ethnicity or religion. The totals also do not reveal who selected a candidate in one race and left another race blank.

When the correct percentage is not enough

The summary reports El-Sayed at 82.16% and Benson at 78.78%, a difference of 3.38 percentage points. Each percentage, however, uses a different denominator: 45,063 counted votes in the Senate race, against 41,404 in the governor's race.

For a comparison with one denominator, Mahjar divided each candidate's votes by all 45,460 ballots. El-Sayed's share becomes 81.45% and Benson's 71.75%, a gap of 9.70 points. These do not replace the published race percentages; they show each candidate's vote total within the city's population of people who cast ballots.

The difference between ballots cast and counted votes is 397 in the Senate race, against 4,056 in the governor's race. The summary does not distinguish selections left blank from votes not counted because more than the permitted number of candidates were selected. It would therefore be wrong to describe all 4,056 as a deliberate boycott of the governor's race or political disengagement.

The party selection is not the whole ballot

The Democratic straight-party selection received 82.05%, but the denominator is 26,717 straight-party selections, not 45,460 ballots. Confusing those denominators creates the false impression that the percentage measures the allegiance of all city voters.

Michigan's general-election instructions allow straight-ticket voting, split-ticket voting with individual candidate selections, or selecting candidates individually. Nonpartisan races and proposals must be voted on separately. A party mark is therefore insufficient to reconstruct each voter's ballot. [3]

Nor does the file directly test the claim that "Arabs and Muslims returned to the Democrats." The city is not one religious group, and geographic totals do not reveal individuals' movement between the 2024 presidential election and the 2026 midterms. The result that can be established is narrower: among the same electorate in one election, the party's candidates performed differently, and the direction of the gap varied by voting channel.

What now needs explaining is not only why El-Sayed led Benson overall, but why that did not happen among absentee voters, and why counted Senate votes were closer to the total number of ballots. An answer requires more detailed precinct and uncounted-vote data, or direct evidence from voters. Their motives cannot be extracted from a results table alone.

Sources

[1] City of Dearborn, 42/42 precincts, unofficial results.

https://dearborn.gov/sites/default/files/2026-11/ElectionSummaryReportRPT42of42_AVandEV.pdf

[2] City results page and update time for the complete version.

https://dearborn.gov/electionresults

[3] Michigan's official ballot-marking instructions, general-election section.

https://www.michigan.gov/sos/-/media/Project/Websites/sos/01mcalpine/Mandated_Ballot.pdf

First published on Mahjar Post on November 4, 2026.
WhatsAppXFacebookEmail
← Back to Mahjar Post

Email newsletter

One short email in English. No noise.

Reports summarised from the sources linked on each story page. Corrections welcome.